Trustee demands probe of judge
By Mitch Hotts
Macomb Daily Staff Writer
A Harrison Township elected official has filed a complaint
with the Michigan Judicial Tenure Commission accusing a Macomb County Circuit
Court judge with misconduct, including abuse of power, bribery and conflict
In a related move, the township's Board of Trustees on
Monday night voted 4-3 to immediately suspend their building department
director for actions he took involving complaints relating to the judge
and her property.
Trustee James Ulinski filed the complaint against Judge
Mary Chrzanowski and said state judicial regulators are reviewing a package
of material he submitted.
"I believe that there is a pattern of abuse of office
that has been shown to exist and the judge clearly used her position overhearing
a case to influence the actions of Harrison Township elected officials,"
Ulinski wrote in his request for an investigation.
Contacted Monday afternoon in her courtroom, Chrzanowski
said she has not been contacted by the Judicial Tenure Commission and denied
"I have no idea what this about," she said. "This guy
(Ulinski) is a kook."
According to a copy of Ulinski's complaint, which was
obtained by The Macomb Daily, a key allegation is the judge failing to
disclose personal or business relationships with parties involved in a
legal dispute with township officials.
In 2005, Chrzanowski was assigned to handle a defamation
case filed by three elected officials against four residents who attempted
a recall. The case involved numerous other parties who filed as counter-defendants
Chrzanowski continued to work on the case through 2006
at which time a settlement was proposed.
About one year later, there was a confrontation between
some of the elected officials and some of the residents involved in the
litigation following a board meeting. The elected officials then filed
to have personal protection orders against the residents following the
That PPO case landed before Chrzanowski who then stated
for the record that she could not oversee it because she had personal or
business relationships with some of the residents involved - the same residents
whose legal case she had heard the year before.
In fact, according to the complaint, the judge - a Harrison
Township resident - attended a board meeting and sat with the wives of
the residents involved in the legal case.
Chrzanowski told The Macomb Daily that she doesn't know
some of the men named in the complaint but did acknowledge coming to a
board meeting. She said she didn't know who she sat by.
Ulinski's complaint states Chrzanowski had personal relationships
with the residents and shouldn't have been involved in the initial case
The complaint also states the judge on several occasions
in the courtroom complained to the elected officials about a dilapidated
residence located next to her home in Harrison Township.
At some point in the spring of 2007, the township's building
department took action to demolish the dwelling, trees and fence next to
the judge's home. The complaint maintains township Treasurer Darrin York
had "passed along" information about the judge's concerns to the building
department in an effort to gain a more favorable ruling on legal issues
the township had before the judge.
An affidavit in the complaint submitted by Sharon Eineman,
another township trustee, indicated York had spoken with the judge about
the personal protection orders and "she would take care of it."
Ulinski's complaint states York's actions to have the
building department expedite the demolition of the house next to the judge
was beyond his authority.
York told The Macomb Daily he never spoke with Chrzanowski
about the rundown house and adamantly denied he had attempted to influence
"There was a court order for that demolition signed by
(circuit court) Judge Richard Caretti," York said. "This is nothing more
than a conspiracy theory by Mr. Ulinski."
Paul Fischer, executive director of the Michigan Judicial
Tenure Commission said he could not comment on whether an investigation
has been initiated. He said any potential probe would not become public
until the JTC issues a formal complaint and a hearing was held.
Meanwhile, the township board voted 4-3 Monday to suspend
building official Vijary Parakh over the demolition issue. The board set
up a committee to investigate the allegations against Parakh and report
back to them.
Parakh was not at the meeting and did not immediately
respond to a phone call at his home for comment.
Copyright© 2008 by Citizens for Legal Responsibility®. All rights reserved. email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Return to Home Page
Created July 30, 2008